WaveRate / Guides / Why Do Banks Give Bad Exchange Rates?

Exchange rate basics

Why Do Banks Give Bad Exchange Rates?

Published 2026-11-07 · Updated 2026-11-07 · 7 min read · By WaveRate

You look up the euro before a trip, then walk into your bank and the rate on the board is noticeably worse. Nobody made a mistake. The rate a bank quotes you is not the market rate: it is the market rate with the bank's price built into it. Some of that price pays for real costs, some of it is plain profit, and almost none of it is shown as a separate fee. Once you see how it is put together, you can measure it on any quote.

A traveller at a teller window in a marble bank hall, the teller passing her notes as a few coins drop into his drawer

Two rates on the board, one rate in the middle

A bank or exchange office usually shows two prices for a currency: the rate at which it buys it from you and the rate at which it sells it to you. It always buys low and sells high. The mid-market rate, the midpoint of what large banks pay each other on the wholesale market, sits somewhere between the two. That midpoint is what a converter app or a search engine shows you, and it is the only neutral benchmark, because nobody earns anything at it.

The gap between the rate you get and the mid-market rate is the bank's price for the conversion. You can see how large it can be when you buy and sell straight back. Australia's competition regulator, the ACCC, gave an example from Sydney Airport on 12 February 2019 in its 2019 report on foreign currency services: a traveller changing 100 Australian dollars into pounds and immediately selling them back to the same counter would have ended up with about 55 dollars, before any fees. That is an airport counter, where prices are at their worst, but the mechanism is the same everywhere.

The margin is the fee you do not see

A fee printed on a receipt is easy to compare. A margin hidden inside the rate is not, because you only notice it if you work out what the mid-market rate would have given you. That is why "no commission" and "0% fees" are such popular slogans: the charge has not disappeared, it has moved into the rate.

The ACCC's 2019 report put numbers on one real case. Buying 200 US dollars in cash at an airport on 12 February 2019 cost the traveller 330 Australian dollars. Using the benchmark rate of that day as a stand-in for the counter's own cost, the ACCC put the dollars at about 283 Australian dollars; the counter's rate added a margin of about 35, and its fees added 12. The report also found that the suppliers with the lowest up-front fees were more expensive than other suppliers, and it warned travellers to be wary of "no fees, no commissions" offers, which may distract from an unfavourable exchange rate.

  • A visible fee: a fixed charge or percentage listed separately.
  • A margin: the difference between the offered rate and the mid-market rate, folded into the price.
  • The total price: both together, which is the only figure worth comparing.

What the margin pays for

Not all of it is greed. Part of a bank's margin covers real costs, and knowing them explains why some conversions are much dearer than others.

Cash is expensive to handle. Banknotes have to be ordered, shipped, insured, counted, stored and guarded, and a branch has to keep a stock of currencies that may sit unused for weeks. Notes it buys back from travellers have to be checked and sent back again. None of this exists when money moves between accounts, which is one reason a card payment or a transfer is usually converted more cheaply than a stack of banknotes.

A fixed rate in a moving market carries risk. Many banks publish a rate sheet for the day, or update it only a few times, while the wholesale market moves every second. If the bank promises you a price in the morning, it needs a buffer in case the market turns against it by the afternoon. The less often a rate is updated, the wider that buffer tends to be. Volatile periods and weekends, when interbank trading pauses and the bank cannot cover its position until the market reopens, can widen it further.

The rest is commercial. Banks know that many customers convert out of habit, at the branch they already use, without comparing. The ACCC found that loyalty to the big four banks cost Australian consumers money, and that those banks began lowering their prices once new competitors arrived and informed customers started to switch. That finding is from one country in 2019, but the incentive it describes applies wherever customers do not compare.

Why cash and less common currencies cost more

The two costs above add up fastest for banknotes in currencies that few people buy. A bank in Germany sells US dollars and pounds every day, so the notes move quickly and it can price them tightly. Notes for a less common currency may have to be ordered specially, held for longer and sold in small volumes, so each sale carries more of the handling cost. The wholesale market for such currencies is also thinner, with fewer banks trading them, so the bank's own buying price is less favourable and moves more.

In practice this means two things. First, the spread you saw on euros or dollars says little about the spread on, say, Vietnamese dong or Moroccan dirham at the same counter. Second, a currency that is hard to find at home is often cheaper to obtain in the destination country, for example from an ATM with a suitable card, than as banknotes bought before you leave. Check rather than assume: some currencies are restricted or rarely held abroad, and local ATM fees vary.

Card, cash or transfer: three different price tags

Card payments abroad are usually converted at the card network's rate, which tends to be close to the market, and your bank may add a foreign transaction fee on top. In the ACCC's 2019 comparison, payment cards were generally cheaper than foreign cash, travel cards and international transfers for overseas purchases. The big exception is a terminal or ATM offering to charge you in your home currency: that conversion is done by the merchant's side at its own rate, so choose the local currency instead.

In the European Union the rules make card margins easier to see. Under EU regulation on cross-border payments, card issuers have to express their currency conversion charges for payments in other EU currencies as a percentage mark-up over the latest euro reference rates of the European Central Bank, and send you that figure by electronic message after a card payment or ATM withdrawal in such a currency, unless you opt out. The ECB itself publishes those reference rates once per working day, around 16:00 CET, for information only.

Bank transfers abroad combine a fee, a margin in the rate and sometimes charges deducted along the way by other banks. Their cost depends heavily on the provider and the destination, so the only reliable comparison is the amount that arrives, in the recipient's currency.

How to check any bank quote

  1. Look up the mid-market rate first. Open the currency pair in WaveRate or any converter shortly before you convert. Note the rate and the time: it is your benchmark, not a price anyone will give you.
  2. Ask for the total, not the rate. Ask the bank or exchange office how much you will pay or receive in your own currency, with every fee included. A rate alone hides the fees; a fee alone hides the margin.
  3. Convert the same amount at the benchmark. Type the amount into WaveRate's calculator. The difference between its result and the bank's total is the full cost of the conversion, in money you can weigh.
  4. Compare the method you will actually use. Cash, card and transfer are priced differently. Compare quotes for the same method, and check your card's foreign transaction fee before assuming the card is the cheaper option.
  5. Decide whether the gap matters. On a small amount the difference may not be worth a second trip. On a large one, such as a deposit abroad, it usually is worth getting more than one total.
WaveRate's calculator converting an amount at the reference rate
Convert the amount at the reference rate, then set it beside the bank's total to see the whole margin in money.

Questions people ask

Why is the bank's exchange rate different from the one on Google?

Search engines and converter apps show the mid-market rate, the midpoint of wholesale trading. A bank quotes a retail rate with its margin built in, and it may also set that rate once or a few times a day while the market keeps moving. The difference between the two is the bank's price for the conversion.

Is "no commission" currency exchange really free?

Usually not. The cost moves into the exchange rate instead of a separate fee. Australia's competition regulator found in 2019 that suppliers with the lowest up-front fees were more expensive than others, so compare the total amount you get, not the fee.

Is your own bank the cheapest place to change money?

Often not. In its 2019 inquiry, Australia's competition regulator found the big four banks were consistently more expensive than some other suppliers for foreign cash and international transfers, and never the cheapest option for common currencies such as the US dollar and the pound in its price data. That is one country's finding, so compare the total amount from more than one provider wherever you are.

Why are rates worse for less common currencies?

Fewer people buy them, so banks hold small stocks for longer and spread the handling cost over fewer sales. The wholesale market for them is also thinner, which makes the bank's own price less favourable. The margin on a minor currency can be much wider than on the euro or the US dollar.

How can I tell how much margin a bank is charging?

Convert the same amount at the current mid-market rate and compare it with the total the bank quotes in your currency, fees included. The difference divided by the mid-market result is the total cost as a percentage. In the EU, card issuers must also state the conversion charge on card payments in another EU currency as a mark-up over the ECB reference rate.

WaveRate provides reference exchange-rate information only. It does not execute currency exchanges and is not financial, investment, or trading advice.